Guys this is contemporaneous work. Eric has emails and conversations dating back to 1970s to prove that this paper was written since then. The only issue is that they did an early literature review.
2022 JF Paper copies 1993 B journal paper
-
The finance academia, the journal review process in particular, has serious flaws. But the most powerful, who are journal editors and presidents of the major associations, have no incentives to fix because they benefit from the flaws.
It is so funny to watch finance academics blame politicians and capitalists for cronyism, without pointing out their own cronyism.
-
It's not funny, it's optiomal
The finance academia, the journal review process in particular, has serious flaws. But the most powerful, who are journal editors and presidents of the major associations, have no incentives to fix because they benefit from the flaws.
It is so funny to watch finance academics blame politicians and capitalists for cronyism, without pointing out their own cronyism. -
It is not. I need to check out ASAP.
The JF paper miscites the B paper in a small footnote. (earlier drafts ignored it completely)
Chicago authors are known to lie, cheat, and steal. e.g.,:
https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/actual-fraud-at-jar
https://www.econjobrumors.com/topic/hrm-strategy-for-publishing-in-rfsMisciting in a footnote. What a disgrace.
Why do we all keep pretending that the game is fair
-
That footnote is a clear violation of AFA’s code of conduct and ethics
(b) Plagiarism – In publications, presentations, teaching, practice, and service, financial economists should explicitly identify, credit, and reference the author when they take data or material verbatim from another person’s written work, whether it is published, unpublished, or electronically available, and acknowledge and reference the use of others’ work, even if the work is not quoted verbatim or paraphrased, and they should not present others’ work as their own. They should report cases of plagiarism to the appropriate organizations such as journals or publishers.