In Finance, Melb is dropping fast. Questionable tenure decisions, health issues and sudden deaths, its really terrible, but there is no way they are even with UNSW now. Maybe marginally above Monash.
Finance displine, Melbourne=unsw>u sydney, monash and anu> UQ and adelaide>uwa
Especially after RA left.
Sure!
they have been hiring lemons for years. Although doing a good job recently at moving them on.
Good point! Melbourne is good at hiring lemons.
As if they could. Not many of them have a CV that generates outside options. SR is probably the only movable AP, whereas some others don't even have any top publication.
Melbourne falling apart. Everyone desperate to leave
monash did pretty well in the recent senior/seasoned markets: stockholm (network/labor), warwick (labor), zurich (labor/macro), yale (network/io), mannheim (io), auckland (io), hkust (experiment/theory), cmu (experiment). all happened in the last 5 years, but count for 50% total output now.you must be one of those guys you listed. fess up.
Monash isn't a good university. Its intellectual atmosphere is dreadful, at least in the areas of economics and management. It has an aggressive management which prevents academics from developing a coherent and long-term research agenda. They just want publications, lots of them, now! The outcome is that academic misconduct is rampant, with guest and honor authorship being a widespread practice.
On top of that, I'm shocked to see how students, the majority from Asia, are riped-off. Beside the fees their families have to pay, they don't even count on free study rooms. Students have to rent them by the hour, if they want to meet classmates to study or do group assignments. Poor fellas...
Riped-off? Upset Asian bro that didn’t get a job at Monash detected. Let me guess, a UQ PhD student?
monash did pretty well in the recent senior/seasoned markets: stockholm (network/labor), warwick (labor), zurich (labor/macro), yale (network/io), mannheim (io), auckland (io), hkust (experiment/theory), cmu (experiment). all happened in the last 5 years, but count for 50% total output now.you must be one of those guys you listed. fess up.
Monash isn't a good university. Its intellectual atmosphere is dreadful, at least in the areas of economics and management. It has an aggressive management which prevents academics from developing a coherent and long-term research agenda. They just want publications, lots of them, now! The outcome is that academic misconduct is rampant, with guest and honor authorship being a widespread practice.
On top of that, I'm shocked to see how students, the majority from Asia, are riped-off. Beside the fees their families have to pay, they don't even count on free study rooms. Students have to rent them by the hour, if they want to meet classmates to study or do group assignments. Poor fellas...