Thanks guys, that was very constructive. Taking a convex combination of all your comments, i'll go with
Tier 1: JME, AEJ Macro
Tier 2: RED
Tier 3: JMCB, JEDC
Tier 4: MD, JMacro
And I'll please the acrymonious micro guy above by making the equivalent list for Micro
Tier 1: JET, TE
Tier 2: AEJ:Micro, Rand
Tier 3: GEB
Tier 4: ET
Best to all. OP
Agree!
Thanks guys, that was very constructive. Taking a convex combination of all your comments, i'll go with
Tier 1: JME, AEJ Macro
Tier 2: RED
Tier 3: JMCB, JEDC
Tier 4: MD, JMacro
And I'll please the acrymonious micro guy above by making the equivalent list for Micro
Tier 1: JET, TE
Tier 2: AEJ:Micro, Rand
Tier 3: GEB
Tier 4: ET
Best to all. OP
This!
Tier 1: JME, AEJ Macro
Tier 2: RED
Tier 3: JMCB, JEDC
Tier 4: MD, JMacro
JME~AEJMacro~JEEA>EJ~IER>RED>JMCB~EER>JEDC>>>MD~JMacro~JIMF
EJ and IER is not necessarily better than RED.
JEDC is probably just weakly better than MD.
I have never read any paper in JIMF (what is it?)
This!
Tier 1: JME, AEJ Macro
Tier 2: RED
Tier 3: JMCB, JEDC
Tier 4: MD, JMacro
JME~AEJMacro~JEEA>EJ~IER>RED>JMCB~EER>JEDC>>>MD~JMacro~JIMFEJ and IER is not necessarily better than RED.
JEDC is probably just weakly better than MD.
I have never read any paper in JIMF (what is it?)
IER and EJ are certainly better than RED (especially the former).
This!
Tier 1: JME, AEJ Macro
Tier 2: RED
Tier 3: JMCB, JEDC
Tier 4: MD, JMacro
JME~AEJMacro~JEEA>EJ~IER>RED>JMCB~EER>JEDC>>>MD~JMacro~JIMFEJ and IER is not necessarily better than RED.
JEDC is probably just weakly better than MD.
I have never read any paper in JIMF (what is it?)IER and EJ are certainly better than RED (especially the former).
About the same.