Please name the AP. He deserves to be named-and-shamed.
Last year a grad student tried to present her (practice) JMP in a lunch seminar at my department. One of the APs (who often does stuff like this) held her up for nearly 20 minutes on her *motivation* slide. He was quibbling about her interpretation of every related paper.
That's a real d*ck move. Leaving a seminar is not.
LK does this
Please name the AP. He deserves to be named-and-shamed.Last year a grad student tried to present her (practice) JMP in a lunch seminar at my department. One of the APs (who often does stuff like this) held her up for nearly 20 minutes on her *motivation* slide. He was quibbling about her interpretation of every related paper.
That's a real d*ck move. Leaving a seminar is not.
LK does this
LK at which school? There are more than one LK's.
Please name the AP. He deserves to be named-and-shamed.Last year a grad student tried to present her (practice) JMP in a lunch seminar at my department. One of the APs (who often does stuff like this) held her up for nearly 20 minutes on her *motivation* slide. He was quibbling about her interpretation of every related paper.
That's a real d*ck move. Leaving a seminar is not.
LK does this
LK at which school? There are more than one LK's.
minnesota
So anyone who runs for an AEA position is going to have sh-t dug up about them and be publicly vilified? For little pay and tons of administrative duties? The incentives sound just about right.
Maybe not everyone is after money.
Some people like the power, influence and prestige that goes with it.
I am a senior, and I would never bully a junior to "maintaining harmony of the community". What community are you talking about here? We are not a gay club?
Seniors would persuade her to delete the tweet for the sake of maintaining harmony of the community. With that reasoning, it's hard for Stevenson to refute the request. Card will be elected AEA president and serve out his term without further disturbances. A few years down the road, Stevenson will get tenure. The community will move on like nothing happened.
Mental illness is strong with you, no?
Why would seniors want to persuade her to delete her tweet, and why would she comply even if they do so?Lol the David James dude deleted his accusatory tweetPretty soon Stevenson will also delete her tweet. Behind the scene, some seniors will persuade her to do so and she will comply. In 6 months the community will move on and everyone will act like nothing happened.
Particularly phonies and political hacks like Card, they crave to be seen as important "scholars" more than anything else, because they know they are not scholars, they are phonies and hacks.
So anyone who runs for an AEA position is going to have sh-t dug up about them and be publicly vilified? For little pay and tons of administrative duties? The incentives sound just about right.Maybe not everyone is after money.
Some people like the power, influence and prestige that goes with it.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.
Even graduate students are adults and should recognize their own mistake, rather than expecting that more senior people put up with any kind of crap just because they are more senior. More senior people also have many more things to do to be willing to waste time on spoiled crybabies.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.
Quit being so misogynistic towards this young scholar. Shame.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.Quit being so misogynistic towards this young scholar. Shame.
Nothing of why I wrote is gender specific. It applies to all genders. Yours is just a gratuitous insult with no content.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.Quit being so misogynistic towards this young scholar. Shame.
Nothing of why I wrote is gender specific. It applies to all genders. Yours is just a gratuitous insult with no content.
You're attacking a young vulnerable woman for explaining how an well established man made her feel alienated. How you don't see that as misogynistic shows how much work we have left to do as a profession.
You’re feeding the troll ;)
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.Quit being so misogynistic towards this young scholar. Shame.
Nothing of why I wrote is gender specific. It applies to all genders. Yours is just a gratuitous insult with no content.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.Quit being so misogynistic towards this young scholar. Shame.
Nothing of why I wrote is gender specific. It applies to all genders. Yours is just a gratuitous insult with no content.
You're attacking a young vulnerable woman for explaining how an well established man made her feel alienated. How you don't see that as misogynistic shows how much work we have left to do as a profession.
Pretty sure you are just trolling but these days, can't tell.....
This is a brilliant post. I’ve gone over it at least four times, and I still can’t tell whether it is satire.
I am a senior woman in the profession and I am shocked by the entitlement and blindness of the Twitter poster. The experience should have been traumatic in the sense of the presenter understanding she was the one who screwed up, not Card.
What I learn from this is to be even more selective about the seminar I go to. That is, if I cannot leave during a weak seminar by someone who is not interested in learning to do better work, it is best not to go at all. Life is too short to waste.Quit being so misogynistic towards this young scholar. Shame.
Nothing of why I wrote is gender specific. It applies to all genders. Yours is just a gratuitous insult with no content.
You're attacking a young vulnerable woman for explaining how an well established man made her feel alienated. How you don't see that as misogynistic shows how much work we have left to do as a profession.
Last year a grad student tried to present her (practice) JMP in a lunch seminar at my department. One of the APs (who often does stuff like this) held her up for nearly 20 minutes on her *motivation* slide. He was quibbling about her interpretation of every related paper.
That's a real d*ck move. Leaving a seminar is not.
LK does this
LK at which school? There are more than one LK's.
minnesota
Who was the student?
Please name the AP. He deserves to be named-and-shamed.
Last year a grad student tried to present her (practice) JMP in a lunch seminar at my department. One of the APs (who often does stuff like this) held her up for nearly 20 minutes on her *motivation* slide. He was quibbling about her interpretation of every related paper.
That's a real d*ck move. Leaving a seminar is not.
Nick Ryan
Please name the AP. He deserves to be named-and-shamed.
Last year a grad student tried to present her (practice) JMP in a lunch seminar at my department. One of the APs (who often does stuff like this) held her up for nearly 20 minutes on her *motivation* slide. He was quibbling about her interpretation of every related paper.
That's a real d*ck move. Leaving a seminar is not.
Wolfers is known to be pretty rude during presentations.