Close

Complete Captcha

• 1 year - 226 posts - Latest - RSS
• Thread: 139 Goods vs 37 No Goods

1. Economist
   9ffe
   

   NAUGHTY. MISSING SOME VLRM SCHOOLS.
   I looked at the website ranking. The whole thing including those who had only one total publication in JF/JFE/RFS/JFQA in the last decade. My VLRM school is missing from the ranking although we have over a dozen publication in the same period. My school shows up in ASU ranking.
   SO THIS RANKING IS MISSING SOME VLRM SCHOOLS.

   I agree. There are a bunch of VLRM missing with much better publication records than many schools in the 70-141 range. It does not affect the top 50, but it does affect the top 100 and of course the top 141 with "all" schools. You cannot obtain a reliable top 100 ranking from this website.

   1 year ago # QUOTE 1 Volod 0 Vlad !

2. Economist
   9ffe
   

   ^ If the authors are reading this thread, there is a simple fix. Please run the ASU ranking for the last 5 years or so, and add at least all schools ranked in the top 150 to your list. If they do this, their website might become the best ranking available.

   1 year ago # QUOTE 1 Volod 1 Vlad !

3. Economist
   78c4
   

   51 UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN-MADISON

   No Wisc

   1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

4. Economist
   316c
   

   Oh good

   51 UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN-MADISON

   No Wisc

   1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

5. Economist
   d6c7
   

   For some reason, I can not access ranking - can anyone run 2010-2020, top 50 or 100 finance top 3 journals only, and post it here, please?

   1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

6. Economist
   b10c
   

   For some reason, I can not access ranking - can anyone run 2010-2020, top 50 or 100 finance top 3 journals only, and post it here, please?

   Try this: https://cfar-ranking.olin.wustl.edu/

   1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

7. Economist
   d6c7
   

   Still, not loading even after several minutes.

   1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

8. Economist
   036b
   

   Thank you for the ranking service. Our department will use this to replace UTD ranking site.

   1 year ago # QUOTE 1 Volod 0 Vlad !

9. Economist
   78c4
   

   It works just fine. I have run it several times.

   First you must set your year range 2010 to 2020, then hit the apply button.

   It will take 2 minutes and 15 seconds to run. Be patient!

   Still, not loading even after several minutes.

   1 year ago # QUOTE 1 Volod 0 Vlad !

10. Economist
    1db5
    

    Site still in Beta
    It’s normal
    Hope they buy a better server

    It works just fine. I have run it several times.
    First you must set your year range 2010 to 2020, then hit the apply button.
    It will take 2 minutes and 15 seconds to run. Be patient!

    Still, not loading even after several minutes.
    

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

11. Economist
    3f45
    

    Any ranking you make, Harvard is number 1. Take that Booth, Stanford and MIT!

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

12. Economist
    f49c
    

    I bet it is Harvard Econ not HBS.

    Any ranking you make, Harvard is number 1. Take that Booth, Stanford and MIT!

    1 year ago # QUOTE 1 Volod 0 Vlad !

13. Economist
    3e1e
    

    Based on pubs in top 3 finance and top 5 econ.

    1 Chicago
    2 Harvard
    3 MIT
    4 Stanford
    5 Berkeley
    6 Columbia
    7 Northwestern
    8 Princeton
    9 NYU
    10 Duke
    11 Ohio State
    12 Yale
    13 Dartmouth
    14 UNC
    15 LBS
    16 BC
    17 Cornell
    18 Wharton
    19 Michigan
    20 Washington
    21 UT Austin
    22 UCLA
    23 LSE
    24 Minnesota
    25 UCSD
    26 SSE
    27 HEC
    28 CMU
    29 WashU
    30 UIUC
    31 BU
    32 Indiana
    33 CalTech
    34 Rice
    35 Oxford
    36 Georgetown
    37 USC
    38 UNSW
    39 Geneva
    40 Lausanne
    41 Hong Kong
    42 Purdue
    43 UBC
    44 Maryland
    45 NUS
    46 Toronto
    47 Georgia State
    48 Wisconsin
    49 Miami
    50 ASU

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

14. Economist
    c927
    

    https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3961001
    TOP 25
    1 Harvard University
    2 University Of Chicago
    3 University Of California, Berkeley
    4 MIT
    5 Duke University
    6 Yale University
    7 Stanford University
    8 Cornell University
    9 New York University
    10 Ohio State University, Columbus
    11 Northwestern Univeristy
    12 Dartmouth College
    13 Washington University In St. Louis
    14 London Business School
    15 University Of California, Los Angeles
    16 California Institute Of Technology
    17 University Of North Carolina
    18 Columbia University
    19 Princeton University
    20 University Of Michigan, Ann Arbor
    21 Wharton School Of The University Of Pennsylvania
    22 Boston College
    23 University Of California, San Diego
    24 University Of California, Irvine
    25 Rice University
    NEXT 25
    26 Georgia State University
    27 University Of Texas At Austin
    28 University Of Geneva
    29 Indiana University
    30 Carnegie Mellon University
    31 Purdue University
    32 University Of Minnesota
    33 University Of Washington, Seattle
    34 University Of Virginia
    35 London School Of Economics
    36 University Of California, Davis
    37 University Of Oxford
    38 Tilburg University
    39 HEC Paris
    40 University Of British Columbia
    41 University Of Maryland
    42 INSEAD
    43 Arizona State University
    44 University Of Rochester
    45 Georgia Institute Of Technology
    46 National University Of Singapore
    47 University Of New South Wales
    48 University Of Lausanne
    49 Georgetown University
    50 University Of Miami

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

15. Economist
    78c4
    

    On your list Boston College moves up in the ranking very nicely. Therefore you must be a Boston College benefactor.

    Based on pubs in top 3 finance and top 5 econ.
    1 Chicago
    2 Harvard
    3 MIT
    4 Stanford
    5 Berkeley
    6 Columbia
    7 Northwestern
    8 Princeton
    9 NYU
    10 Duke
    11 Ohio State
    12 Yale
    13 Dartmouth
    14 UNC
    15 LBS
    16 BC
    17 Cornell
    18 Wharton
    19 Michigan
    20 Washington
    21 UT Austin
    22 UCLA
    23 LSE
    24 Minnesota
    25 UCSD
    26 SSE
    27 HEC
    28 CMU
    29 WashU
    30 UIUC
    31 BU
    32 Indiana
    33 CalTech
    34 Rice
    35 Oxford
    36 Georgetown
    37 USC
    38 UNSW
    39 Geneva
    40 Lausanne
    41 Hong Kong
    42 Purdue
    43 UBC
    44 Maryland
    45 NUS
    46 Toronto
    47 Georgia State
    48 Wisconsin
    49 Miami
    50 ASU

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

16. Economist
    78c4
    

    Everyone is trying to make their school look better. The truth hurts!

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

17. Economist
    7e95
    

    Everyone is trying to make their school look better. The truth hurts!

    No, this is a great ranking service
    Let’s give it a prop

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

18. Economist
    7e95
    

    Not from BC

    On your list Boston College moves up in the ranking very nicely. Therefore you must be a Boston College benefactor.

    Based on pubs in top 3 finance and top 5 econ.
    1 Chicago
    2 Harvard
    3 MIT
    4 Stanford
    5 Berkeley
    6 Columbia
    7 Northwestern
    8 Princeton
    9 NYU
    10 Duke
    11 Ohio State
    12 Yale
    13 Dartmouth
    14 UNC
    15 LBS
    16 BC
    17 Cornell
    18 Wharton
    19 Michigan
    20 Washington
    21 UT Austin
    22 UCLA
    23 LSE
    24 Minnesota
    25 UCSD
    26 SSE
    27 HEC
    28 CMU
    29 WashU
    30 UIUC
    31 BU
    32 Indiana
    33 CalTech
    34 Rice
    35 Oxford
    36 Georgetown
    37 USC
    38 UNSW
    39 Geneva
    40 Lausanne
    41 Hong Kong
    42 Purdue
    43 UBC
    44 Maryland
    45 NUS
    46 Toronto
    47 Georgia State
    48 Wisconsin
    49 Miami
    50 ASU
    

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

19. Economist
    ed2c
    

    Based on pubs in top 3 finance and top 5 econ.
    1 Chicago
    2 Harvard
    3 MIT
    4 Stanford
    5 Berkeley
    6 Columbia
    7 Northwestern
    8 Princeton
    9 NYU
    10 Duke
    11 Ohio State
    12 Yale
    13 Dartmouth
    14 UNC
    15 LBS
    16 BC
    17 Cornell
    18 Wharton
    19 Michigan
    20 Washington
    21 UT Austin
    22 UCLA
    23 LSE
    24 Minnesota
    25 UCSD
    26 SSE
    27 HEC
    28 CMU
    29 WashU
    30 UIUC
    31 BU
    32 Indiana
    33 CalTech
    34 Rice
    35 Oxford
    36 Georgetown
    37 USC
    38 UNSW
    39 Geneva
    40 Lausanne
    41 Hong Kong
    42 Purdue
    43 UBC
    44 Maryland
    45 NUS
    46 Toronto
    47 Georgia State
    48 Wisconsin
    49 Miami
    50 ASU

    biased against small departments.

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

20. Economist
    c927
    

    You can see per capita rank too.

    TOP 25
    1 Harvard University
    2 University Of Chicago
    3 University Of California, Berkeley
    4 MIT
    5 Duke University
    6 Yale University
    7 Stanford University
    8 Cornell University
    9 New York University
    10 Ohio State University, Columbus
    11 Northwestern Univeristy
    12 Dartmouth College
    13 Washington University In St. Louis
    14 London Business School
    15 University Of California, Los Angeles
    16 California Institute Of Technology
    17 University Of North Carolina
    18 Columbia University
    19 Princeton University
    20 University Of Michigan, Ann Arbor
    21 Wharton School Of The University Of Pennsylvania
    22 Boston College
    23 University Of California, San Diego
    24 University Of California, Irvine
    25 Rice University
    NEXT 25
    26 Georgia State University
    27 University Of Texas At Austin
    28 University Of Geneva
    29 Indiana University
    30 Carnegie Mellon University
    31 Purdue University
    32 University Of Minnesota
    33 University Of Washington, Seattle
    34 University Of Virginia
    35 London School Of Economics
    36 University Of California, Davis
    37 University Of Oxford
    38 Tilburg University
    39 HEC Paris
    40 University Of British Columbia
    41 University Of Maryland
    42 INSEAD
    43 Arizona State University
    44 University Of Rochester
    45 Georgia Institute Of Technology
    46 National University Of Singapore
    47 University Of New South Wales
    48 University Of Lausanne
    49 Georgetown University
    50 University Of Miami

    1 year ago # QUOTE 0 Volod 0 Vlad !

Reply »