New FAZ ranking is out
German Market
-
New FAZ ranking is out
https://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/mehr-wirtschaft/f-a-z-oekonomenranking-der-neue-ernst-der-wirtschaftspolitik-16968054/f-a-z-oekonomenranking-2020-die-tabellen-16965630.htmlWhy is Thomas Piketty in the list "Politik"? Otherwise they consider only Germans.
-
This describes me perfectly.
After the diploma/master, one searches for a job, gets along well with some professor and works there for several years. The job is nice and part of the job is obtaining the PD degree. But the job is not nice enough (compared with other jobs) such that it is acceptable to move to another country or to perform extensive networking, which both might be necessary to become professor.
Isn't this plausible?OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
-
What are the long-term perspectives of such a career path?
This describes me perfectly.
After the diploma/master, one searches for a job, gets along well with some professor and works there for several years. The job is nice and part of the job is obtaining the PD degree. But the job is not nice enough (compared with other jobs) such that it is acceptable to move to another country or to perform extensive networking, which both might be necessary to become professor.
Isn't this plausible?OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
-
OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
Great joke, but U R assuming that every PD wants to become a professor. I am not sure that this is true, at least not without further restrictions (location, type of university).
You develop a second research agenda that is independent of your PhD research, publish for 5-10 years about it, then you create a document \begin{document}\section{Intro}\section{Content}\input{allpapers.tex}\section{Outro}\end{document}, invite your academic friends to a talk about it and then they give you a stamped certificate: "well done".
You work, say, in industry at a pharma company, and then you can legally co-supervise doctoral students, etc. Many people, many motivations.
What is an alternative Karriereweg (not the old one in your words) that could lead up to a professorship that does not entail achievements similar the idea of a Habilitation? Maybe I'm just old school.
-
OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
Great joke, but U R assuming that every PD wants to become a professor. I am not sure that this is true, at least not without further restrictions (location, type of university).
You develop a second research agenda that is independent of your PhD research, publish for 5-10 years about it, then you create a document <span class="MathJax_Preview" style="color: inherit; display: none;"></span><div class="MathJax_Display"><span class="MathJax" id="MathJax-Element-1-Frame" tabindex="0" style="position: relative;" data-mathml="<math xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="block"><merror><mtext>\begin{document}\section{Intro}\section{Content}\input{allpapers.tex}\section{Outro}\end{document}</mtext></merror></math>" role="presentation"><span class="math" id="MathJax-Span-1" aria-hidden="true" style=""><span class="noError" id="MathJax-Span-2" style="display: inline-block;">\begin{document}\section{Intro}\section{Content}\input{allpapers.tex}\section{Outro}\end{document}</span></span><span class="MJX_Assistive_MathML MJX_Assistive_MathML_Block" role="presentation"><math xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="block"><merror><mtext>\begin{document}\section{Intro}\section{Content}\input{allpapers.tex}\section{Outro}\end{document}</mtext></merror></math></span></span></div><script type="math/tex; mode=display" id="MathJax-Element-1">\begin{document}\section{Intro}\section{Content}\input{allpapers.tex}\section{Outro}\end{document}</script>, invite your academic friends to a talk about it and then they give you a stamped certificate: "well done".
You work, say, in industry at a pharma company, and then you can legally co-supervise doctoral students, etc. Many people, many motivations.
What is an alternative Karriereweg (not the old one in your words) that could lead up to a professorship that does not entail achievements similar the idea of a Habilitation? Maybe I'm just old school.do phd->get TT job->meet objective requirements->become tenured professor
-
nowadays the main reason for getting the habilitation is that it entitles you to four (?) additional years on non-permanent contracts in the public sector... so unless you find a permanent job - which may not be a realistic option - you have to get it at some point...
-
nowadays the main reason for getting the habilitation is that it entitles you to four (?) additional years on non-permanent contracts in the public sector... so unless you find a permanent job - which may not be a realistic option - you have to get it at some point...
Is this actually true??
-
With a small probability you stay in academia otherwise you do something else, e.g., consultancy, data science, some ministry or amt.
What are the long-term perspectives of such a career path?
This describes me perfectly.
After the diploma/master, one searches for a job, gets along well with some professor and works there for several years. The job is nice and part of the job is obtaining the PD degree. But the job is not nice enough (compared with other jobs) such that it is acceptable to move to another country or to perform extensive networking, which both might be necessary to become professor.
Isn't this plausible?OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
-
So there are no problems to find a non-university job, even if you stayed at the university for many years after the phd?
With a small probability you stay in academia otherwise you do something else, e.g., consultancy, data science, some ministry or amt.
What are the long-term perspectives of such a career path?
After the diploma/master, one searches for a job, gets along well with some professor and works there for several years. The job is nice and part of the job is obtaining the PD degree. But the job is not nice enough (compared with other jobs) such that it is acceptable to move to another country or to perform extensive networking, which both might be necessary to become professor.
Isn't this plausible?OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
-
So there are no problems to find a non-university job, even if you stayed at the university for many years after the phd?
With a small probability you stay in academia otherwise you do something else, e.g., consultancy, data science, some ministry or amt.
What are the long-term perspectives of such a career path?
After the diploma/master, one searches for a job, gets along well with some professor and works there for several years. The job is nice and part of the job is obtaining the PD degree. But the job is not nice enough (compared with other jobs) such that it is acceptable to move to another country or to perform extensive networking, which both might be necessary to become professor.
Isn't this plausible?OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
Industry is desperate to hire economists and business guys... You will earn probably as much as the average soccer player at Bayern München. Only 2 phd-graduates I know earn less - because they stayed in academia.
-
Not from what I've observed from others that have done it.
So there are no problems to find a non-university job, even if you stayed at the university for many years after the phd?
With a small probability you stay in academia otherwise you do something else, e.g., consultancy, data science, some ministry or amt.
What are the long-term perspectives of such a career path?
After the diploma/master, one searches for a job, gets along well with some professor and works there for several years. The job is nice and part of the job is obtaining the PD degree. But the job is not nice enough (compared with other jobs) such that it is acceptable to move to another country or to perform extensive networking, which both might be necessary to become professor.
Isn't this plausible?OK, I assume that. What other motivations does somebody have to become a PD then?
-
Aussage gegen Aussage von FAZ gegen Fratzscher auf Twitter ob der letzte DIW Evaluierungsreport ein "sehr gut" für den DIW Vorstand gab oder kritisch über den DIW Vorstand war. Ist das nicht öffentlich zugänglich?
Sorry, aber wer nimmt hier das DIW noch ernst?
Institut für linke Wirtschaftspropaganda und De-Growth.