The weighting of journals must be completely broken by now in order to generate such results.
Quantifying scientific output is silly anyway.
German Market
-
The weighting of journals must be completely broken by now in order to generate such results.
Quantifying scientific output is silly anyway.
The weighting of journals must be completely broken by now in order to generate such results.
Quantifying scientific output is silly anyway.
As an economist, are your really arguing against quantifying output? That seems silly to me.
-
2021 Ranking of individuals
1 Philipp Strack 4,36
2 Benjamin Enke 4,22
3 Michael Weber 3,65
4 Christian Dustmann 3,63
5 Holger Strulik 2,75
6 Iftekhar Hasan 2,70
7 Felix Tintelnot 2,51
8 Dirk Bergemann 2,47
9 Joachim Freyberger 2,45
10 Maximilian Kasy 2,43
11 Matthias Döpke 2,41
12 David Audretsch 2,26
13 Andreas Fuster 2,21
14 Paul Heidhues 2,21
15 Hyun Song Shin 2,18
16 Armin Falk 2,16
17 Florian Zimmermann 2,11
18 Botond Kőszegi 2,10
19 Uwe Sunde 2,03
20 Ulrike Malmendier 2,00
21 Holger Müller 1,99
22 Florin Bilbiie 1,99
23 Holger Sieg 1,97
24 Stephan Lauermann 1,96
25 Ulf Zölitz 1,93
26 Erwan Morellec 1,92
27 Antoinette Schoar 1,92
28 Adriano Rampini 1,90
29 Andreas Mueller 1,87
30 Stefan Nagel 1,86
31 Lorenz Kueng 1,83
32 Axel Ockenfels 1,82
33 Markus Brunnermeier 1,81
34 Hannes Schwandt 1,76
35 Roland Strausz 1,75
36 Carlos Alós-Ferrer 1,74
37 Benny Moldovanu 1,73
38 Christoph Rothe 1,73
39 Francesco Franzoni 1,70
40 Sascha Becker 1,67
41 Ivo Welch 1,67
42 Damian Kozbur 1,65
43 Farzad Saidi 1,65
44 Florian Scheuer 1,62
45 Roman Inderst 1,62
46 Philipp Kircher 1,61
47 Benjamin Moll 1,60
48 Martin Schneider 1,60
49 Kai Gehring 1,59
50 Nicola Fuchs-Schündeln 1,59 -
2021 Ranking of individuals
1 Philipp Strack 4,36
2 Benjamin Enke 4,22
3 Michael Weber 3,65
4 Christian Dustmann 3,63
5 Holger Strulik 2,75
6 Iftekhar Hasan 2,70
7 Felix Tintelnot 2,51
8 Dirk Bergemann 2,47
9 Joachim Freyberger 2,45
10 Maximilian Kasy 2,43
11 Matthias Döpke 2,41
12 David Audretsch 2,26
13 Andreas Fuster 2,21
14 Paul Heidhues 2,21
15 Hyun Song Shin 2,18
16 Armin Falk 2,16
17 Florian Zimmermann 2,11
18 Botond Kőszegi 2,10
19 Uwe Sunde 2,03
20 Ulrike Malmendier 2,00
21 Holger Müller 1,99
22 Florin Bilbiie 1,99
23 Holger Sieg 1,97
24 Stephan Lauermann 1,96
25 Ulf Zölitz 1,93
26 Erwan Morellec 1,92
27 Antoinette Schoar 1,92
28 Adriano Rampini 1,90
29 Andreas Mueller 1,87
30 Stefan Nagel 1,86
31 Lorenz Kueng 1,83
32 Axel Ockenfels 1,82
33 Markus Brunnermeier 1,81
34 Hannes Schwandt 1,76
35 Roland Strausz 1,75
36 Carlos Alós-Ferrer 1,74
37 Benny Moldovanu 1,73
38 Christoph Rothe 1,73
39 Francesco Franzoni 1,70
40 Sascha Becker 1,67
41 Ivo Welch 1,67
42 Damian Kozbur 1,65
43 Farzad Saidi 1,65
44 Florian Scheuer 1,62
45 Roman Inderst 1,62
46 Philipp Kircher 1,61
47 Benjamin Moll 1,60
48 Martin Schneider 1,60
49 Kai Gehring 1,59
50 Nicola Fuchs-Schündeln 1,59Macro non-German AP here. This ranking and other posted in this thread before are jokes, Scheuer at 44, Moll at 47.... Germans get your sh..t together, you are the largest and wealthiest economy in Europe and you should have at least 2-3 world class universities competing with Stanford, Harvard, LSE etc. Instead you just have a dispersed set of mediocre places with incentives upside down...disappointing...
-
^ It's research output in the last 5 years and Scheuer and Moll published well but not that much in the last 5 years.
Yeah, but Moll's impact (look at cites) on the macro profession was really huge. It by output you mean quantity only, that's a joke.
Calm down Benni, we know your contribution to Kaplan's and Violante's work. Why did you switch from growth to business cycle? Mathiness?
-
^ It's research output in the last 5 years and Scheuer and Moll published well but not that much in the last 5 years.
Yeah, but Moll's impact (look at cites) on the macro profession was really huge. It by output you mean quantity only, that's a joke.
Calm down Benni, we know your contribution to Kaplan's and Violante's work. Why did you switch from growth to business cycle? Mathiness?
Not Moll here, non-German macro AP. Regardless of the relative contribution, which I know little about, the guy has cites and impact, you can not deny that. No idea about the switching though.
-
2021 Ranking of individuals
1 Philipp Strack 4,36
2 Benjamin Enke 4,22
3 Michael Weber 3,65
4 Christian Dustmann 3,63
5 Holger Strulik 2,75
6 Iftekhar Hasan 2,70
7 Felix Tintelnot 2,51
8 Dirk Bergemann 2,47
9 Joachim Freyberger 2,45
10 Maximilian Kasy 2,43
11 Matthias Döpke 2,41
12 David Audretsch 2,26
13 Andreas Fuster 2,21
14 Paul Heidhues 2,21
15 Hyun Song Shin 2,18
16 Armin Falk 2,16
17 Florian Zimmermann 2,11
18 Botond Kőszegi 2,10
19 Uwe Sunde 2,03
20 Ulrike Malmendier 2,00
21 Holger Müller 1,99
22 Florin Bilbiie 1,99
23 Holger Sieg 1,97
24 Stephan Lauermann 1,96
25 Ulf Zölitz 1,93
26 Erwan Morellec 1,92
27 Antoinette Schoar 1,92
28 Adriano Rampini 1,90
29 Andreas Mueller 1,87
30 Stefan Nagel 1,86
31 Lorenz Kueng 1,83
32 Axel Ockenfels 1,82
33 Markus Brunnermeier 1,81
34 Hannes Schwandt 1,76
35 Roland Strausz 1,75
36 Carlos Alós-Ferrer 1,74
37 Benny Moldovanu 1,73
38 Christoph Rothe 1,73
39 Francesco Franzoni 1,70
40 Sascha Becker 1,67
41 Ivo Welch 1,67
42 Damian Kozbur 1,65
43 Farzad Saidi 1,65
44 Florian Scheuer 1,62
45 Roman Inderst 1,62
46 Philipp Kircher 1,61
47 Benjamin Moll 1,60
48 Martin Schneider 1,60
49 Kai Gehring 1,59
50 Nicola Fuchs-Schündeln 1,59Not 1 Woman in the TOP15!
Very sad, This simply reflects all the disadvantages faced by female researchers in econ. -
yes and then Boyer and Hagenbach who fulfill none of the two criteria.
I still don’t understand this arbitrary mixture of “some Germans abroad” interspersed with “people at universities in DACH”, no matter whether they or the location of their university is German speaking. Is it so hard to come up with a consistent criterion?
-
Yeah I think the 5 year ranking just fluctuates a little depending on when top 5‘s come out. As someone above pointed out, I think Scheuer was number one in 2019 because he had a bunch of top 5‘s in 2016 that now just dropped out. So you see people like Jaimovich on rank 90, Dorn doesn’t even make it in the top 100, etc.
-
Please guys, vote for RED RED GREEN!!
Germany needs even more culturally incompatible refugees and welfare paras1tes!
And I need my UBI to be financed!
-Southern europoorWe have had red-green before. Experience teaches that such a government means war and social cuts.