of course, this will have practical consequences because the university will have to prove that the researcher failed. otherwise courts will overturn any termination.
btw, if the law will have no effect, why do you think that the hu president resigned? and the dean of the law faculty expressed great admiration for this move?
Denn eins ist auch klar: Europaweit sind wir die Ausnahme. Die Dänen, Schweden, Norweger, Holländer, Belgier, Franzosen, Iren, Spanier, Italiener und Engländer machen es anders als wir.
That's clueless (as the other poster already wrote). All of those countries have incredible inefficiencies and frictions, and even when you think you see a shining example of tenure-track program abroad, it's usually done on private contracts outside the public employment system, or it's done with a very "creative" interpretation of local laws (a level of creativity that would immediately be struck down by German bureaucrats and judges).
"..., wenn sie sich bewähren. " What ever this means, it is flexible enough a condition for that law to have no practical consequences at all.Schulz said successfull habilitation is enough proof.
Exactly. Try to explain to a German Verwaltungsgericht what "two A publications" are, and why the "A" nature of a journal should be a beamtenrechtliches Kriterium. In the end, everybody who wants to sue will sue their way into the system, and your hoped-for tenure track system goes down the drain.
Sachverständige sind auch ein Beweismittel.
"..., wenn sie sich bewähren. " What ever this means, it is flexible enough a condition for that law to have no practical consequences at all.Schulz said successfull habilitation is enough proof.
Exactly. Try to explain to a German Verwaltungsgericht what "two A publications" are, and why the "A" nature of a journal should be a beamtenrechtliches Kriterium. In the end, everybody who wants to sue will sue their way into the system, and your hoped-for tenure track system goes down the drain.
But is the practical implication not obvious? No postdocs in Berlin anymore.
and that's exactly what is already happening:
https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/politik/berliner-unis-reagieren-auf-neues-gesetz-4053/
it's like a textbook case of unintended consequences of badly-designed policies. move over "cobra-effekt", it is now the "berlin-postdoc-effekt".
Can't the Kommunistensenat itself hire these postdocs?
and that's exactly what is already happening:
https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/politik/berliner-unis-reagieren-auf-neues-gesetz-4053/
it's like a textbook case of unintended consequences of badly-designed policies. move over "cobra-effekt", it is now the "berlin-postdoc-effekt".
But is the practical implication not obvious? No postdocs in Berlin anymore.and that's exactly what is already happening:
https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/politik/berliner-unis-reagieren-auf-neues-gesetz-4053/
it's like a textbook case of unintended consequences of badly-designed policies. move over "cobra-effekt", it is now the "berlin-postdoc-effekt".
Wow, what a fight between the Senat and Universities. At the end,only losers, unemployed post-docs, destroyed reputation of Berlin as an academic place and the once more a proof for inability of Berlin's politicians!
But interesting question what this means in general equilibrium. Many postdocs in Berlin seem to have a preference for living in Berlin. So would they be willing to live in Frankfurt? Or do they just drop out of academia?
the equilibrium is that this clownshow will extend bundesweit because we turn into ddr 2.0
But is the practical implication not obvious? No postdocs in Berlin anymore.and that's exactly what is already happening:
https://www.forschung-und-lehre.de/politik/berliner-unis-reagieren-auf-neues-gesetz-4053/
it's like a textbook case of unintended consequences of badly-designed policies. move over "cobra-effekt", it is now the "berlin-postdoc-effekt".Wow, what a fight between the Senat and Universities. At the end,only losers, unemployed post-docs, destroyed reputation of Berlin as an academic place and the once more a proof for inability of Berlin's politicians!
If Berlin was not the capital of Germany, it would be failed city. It must be the long shadows of (1) West-Berlin's alimentation attidue and (2) East-Berlins communist legacy. What can one expect to emerge for this? Now they live off the capital bonus.