总结：固定效应消失术+历史背景修改术。
James Kung: a serial data manipulator
-
如果论文真的有问题，斯坦福大学的Yiqing Xu教授，还会SB一样采访他们？
麻烦看完这个采访再讨论，就可以真正了解陈硕老师
https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/345304218错的就是错的，不管谁采访都是错的。
The following paper critizes the fake data of Shuo Chen and James Kung (2011, APSR).
A Tragedy of the Nomenklatura? Career incentives, political loyalty and political radicalism during China's Great Leap Forward
The UBC PhD dissertation also critizes the fake data of Ting Chen and James Kung's QJE.
It seems that they cannot publish anything with the right datasets.
-
-
这篇评论有意思：
Shiping tang：“这位同学（老师）的态度值得推崇”
Zhiwei Xu：“经济学 除了star war以外 还有theory和结构模型……” -
如果论文真的有问题，斯坦福大学的Yiqing Xu教授，还会SB一样采访他们？
麻烦看完这个采访再讨论，就可以真正了解陈硕老师
https://zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/345304218错的就是错的，不管谁采访都是错的。
The following paper critizes the fake data of Shuo Chen and James Kung (2011, APSR).
A Tragedy of the Nomenklatura? Career incentives, political loyalty and political radicalism during China's Great Leap Forward
The UBC PhD dissertation also critizes the fake data of Ting Chen and James Kung's QJE.
It seems that they cannot publish anything with the right datasets.我好奇很久了，一个芝加哥政治系的正教授说数据造假，居然一点水花都没有！？