One of those rejected paper is my tenure paper
JFE report
-
True maybe for some, but many of these it is clear it is not “high standard” and them either (1) never being trusted with a good paper by an editor, (2) protecting their turf, or (3) being TW’s personal attack dog (Tor Erik Bakke)
So funny how people are focused on high rejection rates. Use your brain for one minute: JFE corrution is fed by high acceptance rates of many referees who might be giving favors to friends by accepting their bad papers. People on this list likely have very high standards. BTW, how would a journal defend its “top” status if all referees accountable %10+ of what they review??
-
Like the old saying: live and let live
Guys and gals on the list got the goods: tenure, editorships, money, fame, summer support, consulting money. Probably making over 600k per annum.
It’s time to be constructive and pay back to the next generation of researchers but to kill them all.
-
Additional list of referees with excessively high rejection rates (0 acceptance out of 15-20 reviews, 1 acceptance out of 20+ reviews, or 2 acceptances out of 50+ reviews):
Loughran, Timothy
Jegadeesh, Narasimhan
Seyhun, H. Nejat
Hadlock, Charles
Barinov, Alexander
Heitzman, Shane M.
Guay, Wayne R.
Kahle, Kathleen
Ready, Robert C.
Hertzel, Michael G
Albuquerque, Rui
Holderness, Clifford
Rouwenhorst, K. Geert
Knyazeva, Anzhela
Fich, Eliezer M.
Pan, Jun
Fahlenbrach, Rudiger
Campello, Murillo
McConnell, John J.
Dew-Becker, Ian
Garleanu, Nicolae
Bhagat, Sanjai
Chernov, Mikhail
Poulsen, Annette
Engelberg, Joseph E.
Purnanandam, Amiyatosh
Reed, Adam V.
Tate, Geoffrey A.
Bakke, Tor-Erik
Opp, Christian C.
Whaley, Robert
Johnson, Timothy C
So, Eric C.
Allayannis, George
Da, Zhi
Schaefer, Scott
Drechsler, Itamar
Gillan, Stuart L.
Kiku, Dana
Gustafson, Matthew
Nini, Gregory
Mann, William
Seasholes, Mark S. -
https://file.io/0uvQB0C1gXfL
Pls save a copy and don't keep posting asking for it. The anon file sharing sites delete the file soonUse this:
-
Good
https://file.io/0uvQB0C1gXfL
Pls save a copy and don't keep posting asking for it. The anon file sharing sites delete the file soonUse this:
https://www.sendspace.com/file/xbyvf2 -
It’s been removed
Curious whyhttps://file.io/0uvQB0C1gXfL
Pls save a copy and don't keep posting asking for it. The anon file sharing sites delete the file soonUse this:
https://www.sendspace.com/file/xbyvf2 -
Links gone already
Guess why?
Can Karl write a story about this and put the file on some permanent server?I already wrote about it briefly, it is #8 on this list:
https://karlstack.substack.com/p/the-top-10-scandals-in-academic-economics?s=w
I do not have the file.
-
Link broken
https://file.io/0uvQB0C1gXfL
Pls save a copy and don't keep posting asking for it. The anon file sharing sites delete the file soonUse this:
https://www.sendspace.com/file/xbyvf2