This is not BS, it has real effects. Journal space is limited and we still only value those three journals.
I think it is normal that people kill each other's paper in our profession. It is a bad equilibrium that we end up with.Still surprised that a person would reject every paper he reviews
Kill others’ paper so your paper has a higher chance to go through? This is bs
Not really
There is no crowd out effect tbh
This is not BS, it has real effects. Journal space is limited and we still only value those three journals.
I think it is normal that people kill each other's paper in our profession. It is a bad equilibrium that we end up with.Still surprised that a person would reject every paper he reviews
Kill others’ paper so your paper has a higher chance to go through? This is bs
Exactly, those who published more than 15 JFEs should be investigated.
This is not BS, it has real effects. Journal space is limited and we still only value those three journals.
I think it is normal that people kill each other's paper in our profession. It is a bad equilibrium that we end up with.Still surprised that a person would reject every paper he reviews
Kill others’ paper so your paper has a higher chance to go through? This is bs
Do you have any evidence on this?
Not really
There is no crowd out effect tbhThis is not BS, it has real effects. Journal space is limited and we still only value those three journals.
I think it is normal that people kill each other's paper in our profession. It is a bad equilibrium that we end up with.Still surprised that a person would reject every paper he reviews
Kill others’ paper so your paper has a higher chance to go through? This is bs
Rank Reports Rank Turnaround Rank Accept Referee Accepts Rejects Reports Accept Rate Turnaround JFE
1 31 225 Bessembinder, Hank 29 186 215 13% 16 1
2 68 159 Ritter, Jay R. 32 173 205 16% 21 1
3 80 31 Smith, Clifford W. 44 150 194 23% 22 1
4 191 212 Harford, Jarrad 25 154 179 14% 27 1
5 314 114 Shanken, Jay 29 141 170 17% 33 1
6 342 385 Pearson, Neil D. 14 155 169 8% 35 1
7 457 237 Murphy, Kevin J. 22 146 168 13% 50 1
8 4 219 Fama, Eugene 20 126 146 14% 8 1
9 366 351 James, Christopher 13 129 142 9% 37 1
10 7 309 Zhang, Lu 14 124 138 10% 9 1
10 80 217 Harvey, Campbell R. 19 119 138 14% 22 1
12 47 391 DeAngelo, Harry 11 126 137 8% 19 1
13 122 440 Officer, Micah S. 9 127 136 7% 24 1
14 275 156 Stulz, René M. 21 113 134 16% 30 1
15 227 97 French, Kenneth R. 23 108 131 18% 28 1
16 17 69 Weisbach, Michael S. 24 104 128 19% 13 1
17 452 180 Kaplan, Steven N. 19 108 127 15% 49 1
18 391 264 Sloan, Richard G. 15 111 126 12% 39 1
19 96 336 Karpoff, Jonathan 12 110 122 10% 23 1
20 290 188 Pastor, Lubos 17 100 117 15% 31 1
20 391 347 Warner, Jerold B. 11 106 117 9% 39 1
22 457 337 Wruck, Karen 11 101 112 10% 50 1
23 342 139 Wurgler, Jeffrey 17 87 104 16% 35 1
24 27 92 Titman, Sheridan 18 84 102 18% 15 0
24 68 424 Yermack, David 7 95 102 7% 21 1
26 47 514 Loughran, Timothy 3 93 96 3% 19 1
26 355 369 Esty, Benjamin 8 88 96 8% 36 1
26 460 21 Morck, Randall 23 73 96 24% 51 0
29 39 115 Subrahmanyam, Avanidhar 16 79 95 17% 18 0
29 227 412 Lowry, Michelle 7 88 95 7% 28 1
29 255 412 Barber, Brad M. 7 88 95 7% 29 1
29 478 244 Brickley, James 12 83 95 13% 54 0
33 68 162 Longstaff, Francis A. 14 77 91 15% 21 1
33 485 42 Johnson, Simon 19 72 91 21% 56 1
35 342 427 Lerner, Josh 6 83 89 7% 35 1
36 31 34 Whited, Toni M. 19 68 87 22% 16 1
36 227 306 Mikkelson, Wayne 9 78 87 10% 28 1
38 421 386 Eckbo, B. Espen 7 78 85 8% 44 0
39 17 264 Edmans, Alex 10 74 84 12% 13 1
39 191 454 Hasbrouck, Joel 5 79 84 6% 27 0
41 68 189 Schultz, Paul H. 12 71 83 14% 21 0
41 96 292 Morellec, Erwan 9 74 83 11% 23 0
41 275 65 Shleifer, Andrei 16 67 83 19% 30 1
44 227 415 Hendershott, Terrance 6 76 82 7% 28 0
44 543 149 Barberis, Nicholas C. 13 69 82 16% 78 0
46 572 276 Lewellen, Jonathan 9 72 81 11% 91 0
47 380 243 Puri, Manju 10 69 79 13% 38 0
47 430 310 Karolyi, G. Andrew 8 71 79 10% 45 1
49 47 46 Hirshleifer, David 16 61 77 21% 19 1
49 314 190 Linck, James S. 11 66 77 14% 33 0
51 460 236 LaPorta, Rafael 10 66 76 13% 51 0
52 80 392 Graham, John 6 69 75 8% 22 1
52 342 227 Werner, Ingrid 10 65 75 13% 35 0
52 355 297 Kostovetsky, Leonard 8 67 75 11% 36 0
55 191 182 Hodrick, Robert J. 11 63 74 15% 27 0
56 191 387 Denis, David J. 6 67 73 8% 27 0
56 380 521 Jegadeesh, Narasimhan 2 71 73 3% 38 0
58 421 43 Campbell, John Y. 15 57 72 21% 44 1
58 436 369 Edelen, Roger 6 66 72 8% 46 0
60 47 76 Kaniel, Ron 13 58 71 18% 19 1
60 421 161 Barclay, Michael J. 11 60 71 15% 44 1
62 12 109 Fisman, Raymond 12 58 70 17% 11 0
62 191 109 Duffie, Darrell 12 58 70 17% 27 1
62 191 275 Dittmar, Amy 8 62 70 11% 27 1
62 483 239 Hentschel, Ludger 9 61 70 13% 55 1
66 303 414 Vega, Clara 5 63 68 7% 32 0
66 507 235 Healy, Paul 9 59 68 13% 61 1
68 122 263 Jorion, Philippe 8 59 67 12% 24 0
68 140 226 Levine, Ross 9 58 67 13% 25 0
70 275 257 Pontiff, Jeffrey 8 58 66 12% 30 0
70 329 116 Allen, Franklin H. 11 55 66 17% 34 0
70 380 298 Wermers, Russ 7 59 66 11% 38 0
73 122 214 Phillips, Gordon M. 9 56 65 14% 24 0
73 366 47 Robinson, David T. 13 52 65 20% 37 0
73 380 26 van Binsbergen, Jules 15 50 65 23% 38 1
73 478 524 Seyhun, H. Nejat 1 64 65 2% 54 0
73 519 ...See full post
98 407 350 Servaes, Henri 5 49 54 9% 41 0
101 255 523 Heitzman, Shane M. 1 52 53 2% 29 0
101 366 17 Pedersen, Lasse Heje 13 40 53 25% 37 0
101 478 17 Gorton, Gary 13 40 53 25% 54 0
104 80 162 Green, Richard C. 8 44 52 15% 22 1
104 303 464 Ivashina, Victoria 3 49 52 6% 32 1
104 430 341 Stambaugh, Robert F. 5 47 52 10% 45 1
107 12 455 Ahern, Kenneth R. 3 48 51 6% 11 0
107 413 155 Chapman, David A. 8 43 51 16% 42 0
107 421 218 Stoll, Hans R. 7 44 51 14% 44 1
110 164 259 Sensoy, Berk A. 6 44 50 12% 26 0
110 255 503 Guay, Wayne R. 2 48 50 4% 29 0
110 436 259 Dunbar, Craig G. 6 44 50 12% 46 0
110 572 211 Jones, Charles M. 7 43 50 14% 91 0
114 342 389 Sadka, Ronnie 4 45 49 8% 35 0
114 380 389 Kelly, Bryan T. 4 45 49 8% 38 1
116 303 369 Thakor, Anjan 4 44 48 8% 32 0
117 452 181 Carpenter, Jennifer 7 40 47 15% 49 0
117 545 240 Shumway, Tyler 6 41 47 13% 79 0
119 96 64 Roll, Richard W. 9 37 46 20% 23 1
119 140 441 Duffee, Gregory R. 3 43 46 7% 25 0
119 140 525 Larcker, David F. 46 0 46 0% 25 0
119 191 173 Faulkender, Michael W. 7 0 46 15% 27 0
119 227 495 Field, Laura Casares 2 0 46 4% 28 0
124 557 366 Chan, Louis 4 0 45 9% 86 0
124 562 160 Novy-Marx, Robert 7 0 45 16% 88 0
124 577 90 Coval, Joshua 8 0 45 18% 95 0
127 35 493 Kahle, Kathleen 2 0 44 5% 17 0
127 191 352 Becker, Bo 4 0 44 9% 27 0
127 303 29 Megginson, William L. 10 0 44 23% 32 0
127 342 425 Doidge, Craig 3 0 44 7% 35 0
127 407 425 Masulis, Ronald W. 3 0 44 7% 41 1
127 504 77 Ait-Sahalia, Yacine 8 0 44 18% 60 0
133 122 213 Roberts, Michael R. 6 0 43 14% 24 0
134 62 264 Gormley, Todd A. 5 0 42 12% 20 0
134 255 190 Korteweg, Arthur G. 6 0 42 14% 29 0
134 471 66 Starks, Laura T. 8 0 42 19% 53 0
134 521 22 Strebulaev, Ilya 10 0 42 24% 67 0
138 398 256 Dann, Larry Y. 5 0 41 12% 40 1
138 436 338 Hutton, Amy P. 4 0 41 10% 46 0
140 96 479 Ready, Robert C. 2 0 40 5% 23 0
140 122 311 Brav, Alon 4 0 40 10% 24 0
140 140 245 Cremers, Martijn K.J. 5 0 40 13% 25 0
140 329 100 Rhodes-Kropf, Matthew 7 0 40 18% 34 0
140 380 245 Mathews, Richmond D. 5 0 40 13% 38 0
140 444 175 Wang, Neng 6 0 40 15% 47 0
140 499 175 Seguin, Paul J. 6 0 40 15% 59 1
140 526 311 Womack, Kent 4 0 40 10% 69 0
140 604 100 Zingales, Luigi 7 0 40 18% 151 0
149 96 162 Nagel, Stefan 6 0 39 15% 23 0
149 140 397 Hoberg, Gerard T. 3 0 39 8% 25 0
149 314 162 Petersen, Mitchell 6 0 39 15% 33 0
152 80 525 Mulherin, J. Harold 38 0 38 0% 22 0
152 140 522 Hertzel, Michael G. 1 0 38 3% 25 0
152 191 396 Kandel, Eugene 3 0 38 8% 27 0
152 227 475 Albuquerque, Rui 2 0 38 5% 28 0
152 578 40 Lo, Andrew W. 8 0 38 21% 96 0
157 164 140 Strahan, Philip E. 6 0 37 16% 26 0
157 275 293 Matvos, Gregor 4 0 37 11% 30 0
157 275 474 Whitelaw, Robert F. 2 0 37 5% 30 0
157 290 293 Walkling, Ralph A. 4 0 37 11% 31 0
157 460 224 Benmelech, Efraim 5 0 37 14% 51 0
157 547 140 Malloy, Christopher 6 0 37 16% 80 0
163 39 116 Gabaix, Xavier 6 0 36 17% 18 0
163 164 520 Holderness, Clifford 1 0 36 3% 26 0
163 191 525 Kang, Jun-Koo 36 0 36 0% 27 0
163 398 369 Chalmers, John 3 0 36 8% 40 0
163 407 466 Adams, Renee B. 2 0 36 6% 41 0
163 504 369 Prabhala, Nagpurnanand 3 0 36 8% 60 0
163 513 466 Lemmon, Michael L. 2 0 36 6% 63 0
163 574 10 Seru, Amit 9 0 36 25% 92 0
171 80 109 Sialm, Clemens 6 0 35 17% 22 0
171 164 109 Koijen, Ralph S.J. 6 0 35 17% 26 0
171 255 109 Hsieh, David A. 6 0 35 17% 29 0
171 303 190 Boehmer, Ekkehart 5 0 35 14% 32 0
171 391 465 Williamson, Rohan 2 0 35 6% 39 0
171 457 47 Brunnermeier, Markus K. 7 0 35 20% 50 0
171 562 519 Rouwenhorst, K. Geert 1 0 35 3% 88 0
178 80 184 Almeida,...See full post
196 191 525 Cohen, Lauren 32 0 32 0% 27 0
196 255 348 Adelino, Manuel 3 0 32 9% 29 0
196 275 514 Pan, Jun 1 0 32 3% 30 0
196 290 348 Bekaert, Geert 3 0 32 9% 31 0
196 513 157 Spatt, Chester S. 5 0 32 16% 63 0
205 47 513 Fahlenbrach, Rudiger 1 0 31 3% 19 0
205 275 238 Linnainmaa, Juhani 4 0 31 13% 30 0
205 314 339 Matsa, David A. 3 0 31 10% 33 0
205 485 339 Schuerhoff, Norman 3 0 31 10% 56 0
205 538 442 Lynch, Anthony W. 2 0 31 6% 76 0
210 1 510 Brown, Stephen J. 1 0 30 3% 6 0
210 96 311 Warusawitharana, Missaka 3 0 30 10% 23 0
210 140 311 He, Zhiguo 3 0 30 10% 25 0
210 191 525 Wahal, Sunil 30 0 30 0% 27 0
210 314 510 Nikolov, Boris 1 0 30 3% 33 0
210 491 311 Gompers, Paul 3 0 30 10% 57 0
210 499 227 Jenter, Dirk 4 0 30 13% 59 0
210 526 116 Lustig, Hanno 5 0 30 17% 69 0
210 533 428 Santa-Clara, Pedro 2 0 30 7% 72 0
210 540 428 Gromb, Denis 2 0 30 7% 77 0
220 164 19 Adrian, Tobias 7 0 29 24% 26 0
220 191 215 Lettau, Martin 4 0 29 14% 27 0
220 227 107 Roussanov, Nikolai 5 0 29 17% 28 0
220 227 423 Parsons, Christopher A. 2 0 29 7% 28 0
220 255 306 Leary, Mark T. 3 0 29 10% 29 0
220 366 215 Long, John 4 0 29 14% 37 1
220 430 107 Ramadorai, Tarun 5 0 29 17% 45 0
220 450 306 Hochberg, Yael V. 3 0 29 10% 48 0
228 17 190 Jiang, Wei 4 0 28 14% 13 0
228 47 507 Campello, Murillo 1 0 28 4% 19 0
228 140 89 Andersen, Torben 5 0 28 18% 25 0
228 191 416 Todorov, Viktor 2 0 28 7% 27 0
228 255 295 Keys, Benjamin 3 0 28 11% 29 0
228 314 416 Lakonishok, Josef 2 0 28 7% 33 0
228 342 190 Hotchkiss, Edith 4 0 28 14% 35 0
228 380 190 Grinblatt, Mark 4 0 28 14% 38 0
228 380 507 McConnell, John J. 1 0 28 4% 38 0
228 468 295 Schnabl, Philipp 3 0 28 11% 52 0
228 547 507 Richardson, Matthew S. 1 0 28 4% 80 0
228 590 190 Wolfenzon, Daniel 4 0 28 14% 106 0
240 140 276 Opp, Marcus 3 0 27 11% 25 0
240 164 276 Marquez, Robert 3 0 27 11% 26 0
240 329 276 Bernstein, Shai Benjamin 3 0 27 11% 34 0
240 436 183 Kole, Stacey 4 0 27 15% 46 0
240 494 276 Kogan, Leonid 3 0 27 11% 58 0
240 511 32 Bolton, Patrick 6 0 27 22% 62 0
240 574 276 Daniel, Kent D. 3 0 27 11% 92 0
240 592 411 MacKinlay, A. Craig 2 0 27 7% 110 0
248 10 505 Dew-Becker, Ian 1 0 26 4% 10 0
248 96 162 Zitzewitz, Eric 4 0 26 15% 23 0
248 140 505 Garleanu, Nicolae 1 0 26 4% 25 0
248 191 397 Helwege, Jean 2 0 26 8% 27 0
248 380 397 Rice, Edward 2 0 26 8% 38 0
248 460 274 Lundblad, Christian 3 0 26 12% 51 0
248 485 397 Sorensen, Morten 2 0 26 8% 56 0
248 594 397 Maksimovic, Vojislav 2 0 26 8% 119 0
256 22 392 Zender, Jaime F. 2 0 25 8% 14 0
256 35 142 Cochrane, John 4 0 25 16% 17 0
256 62 142 Hellmann, Thomas 4 0 25 16% 20 0
256 191 142 Christoffersen, Peter 4 0 25 16% 27 0
256 191 525 Irvine, Paul J. A. 25 0 25 0% 27 0
256 227 392 Smith, Erin 2 0 25 8% 28 0
256 275 47 Welch, Ivo 5 0 25 20% 30 0
256 303 142 Thesmar, David 4 0 25 16% 32 0
256 329 142 Villalonga, Belen 4 0 25 16% 34 0
256 342 259 Shaliastovich, Ivan 3 0 25 12% 35 0
256 366 259 Lamont, Owen 3 0 25 12% 37 0
256 452 47 Goetzmann, William 5 0 25 20% 49 0
256 460 503 Bhagat, Sanjai 1 0 25 4% 51 0
256 540 392 Ruback, Richard S. 2 0 25 8% 77 1
256 550 20 Calomiris, Charles W. 6 0 25 24% 82 0
256 585 142 Palepu, Krishna 4 0 25 16% 101 1
256 600 142 Joslin, Scott 4 0 25 16% 127 0
273 47 369 Ang, Andrew 2 0 24 8% 19 0
273 80 501 Chernov, Mikhail 1 0 24 4% 22 0
273 164 525 Chava, Sudheer 24 0 24 0% 26 0
273 191 525 Brogaard, Jonathan A. 24 0 24 0% 27 0
273 191 525 Mayers, David 24 0 24 0% 27 1
273 191 525 Netter, Jeffry M. 24 0 24 0% 27 0
273 227 501 Poulsen, Annette 1 0 24 4% 28 0
570 531 525 Vorkink, Keith 10 0 10 0% 71 0
570 535 47 Asquith, Paul 2 0 10 20% 74 1
570 562 47 Hanson, Samuel G. 2 0 10 20% 88 0
570 565 311 Carr, Peter 1 0 10 10% 90 0
570 565 311 Myers, Stewart C. 1 0 10 10% 90 0
570 580 47 Blackwell, David 2 0 10 20% 98 0
606 Howell, Sabrina T. 9 0 9 0% 15 0
606 Sarno, Lucio 9 0 9 0% 19 0
606 Yang, Liyan 9 0 9 0% 20 0
606 Peyer, Urs C. 3 0 9 33% 21 0
606 Giroud, Xavier 1 0 9 11% 22 0
606 Cornell, Bradford 2 0 9 22% 23 0
606 Ai, Hengjie 9 0 9 0% 23 0
606 Gao, Janet 9 0 9 0% 23 0
606 Nyborg, Kjell 9 0 9 0% 23 0
606 Ewens, Michael 1 0 9 11% 25 0
606 Gerardi, Kristopher 1 0 9 11% 26 0
606 Kuehn, Lars-Alexander 1 0 9 11% 26 0
606 Bena, Jan 9 0 9 0% 26 0
606 Walden, Johan 2 0 9 22% 27 0
606 Kisgen, Darren James 9 0 9 0% 27 0
606 Kempf, Elisabeth 1 0 9 11% 28 0
606 Zwick, Eric 1 0 9 11% 28 0
606 Aggarwal, Rajesh K. 1 0 9 11% 29 0
606 Tian, Xuan 1 0 9 11% 31 0
606 Nanda, Ramana 1 0 9 11% 32 0
606 Schallheim, James S. 2 0 9 22% 33 0
606 Kim, Hyunseob 9 0 9 0% 33 0
606 Brennan, Michael J. 1 0 9 11% 36 1
606 Glover, Brent 1 0 9 11% 39 0
606 Milbradt, Konstantin 1 0 9 11% 42 0
606 Winton, Andrew 1 0 9 11% 43 0
606 Sheehan, Dennis 1 0 9 11% 45 0
606 Bharath, Sreedhar T. 9 0 9 0% 49 0
606 Hayes, Rachel 9 0 9 0% 51 0
606 Lusardi, Annamaria 2 0 9 22% 52 0
606 Wilhelm, William J. 1 0 9 11% 52 0
606 Mele, Antonio 2 0 9 22% 54 0
606 Jensen, Michael 3 0 9 33% 57 1
606 Gomes, Joao F. 1 0 9 11% 60 0
606 Vuolteenaho, Tuomo 1 0 9 11% 60 0
606 Nanda, Vikram K. 9 0 9 0% 73 0
606 Carlson, Murray 2 0 9 22% 113 0
606 Cohen, Randolph 1 0 9 11% 118 0
644 Vetsuypens, Michael 2 0 8 25% 16 0
644 Claessens, Stijin 1 0 8 13% 16 0
644 Zhong, Hongda 1 0 8 13% 18 0
644 Giannetti, Mariassunta 8 0 8 0% 18 0
644 Yan, Hongjun 1 0 8 13% 19 0
644 Manela, Asaf 8 0 8 0% 22 0
644 Hebert, Benjamin 2 0 8 25% 23 0
644 Derrien, Francois 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Gao, Pengjie (Paul) 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Maug, Ernst 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Sosyura, Denis 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Farre-Mensa, Joan 8 0 8 0% 24 0
644 Bigio, Saki 1 0 8 13% 25 0
644 Jacobs, Kris 1 0 8 13% 25 0
644 Beck, Thorsten 1 0 8 13% 26 0
644 Goldman, Eitan 8 0 8 0% 26 0
644 Boyer, Brian 1 0 8 13% 27 0
644 Pagel, Michaela 1 0 8 13% 27 0
644 Xiao, Kairong 1 0 8 13% 27 0
644 Haddad, Valentin 1 0 8 13% 28 0
644 Appel, Ian R. 8 0 8 0% 28 0
644 Benzoni, Luca 1 0 8 13% 30 0
644 George, Thomas J. 1 0 8 13% 31 0
644 Brown, Gregory W. 8 0 8 0% 32 0
644 Loutskina, Elena 8 0 8 0% 32 0
644 Simsek, Alp 2 0 8 25% 33 0
644 Schrand, Catherine 8 0 8 0% 34 0
644 Beshears, John 2 0 8 25% 41 0
644 Siriwardane, Emil N. 1 0 8 13% 43 0
644 McCormick, Robert 2 0 8 25% 45 0
644 Lewis, Craig M. 1 0 8 13% 45 0
644 Wedig, Gerard 8 0 8 0% 45 0
644 Bris, Arturo 8 0 8 0% 47 0
644 McNichols, Maureen 2 0 8 25% 53 0
644 Carey, Mark 1 0 8 13% 56 0
644 Lewellen, Katharina 8 0 8 0% 69 0
644 Smith, Abbie J. 2 0 8 25% 74 0
644 Bradshaw, Mark 1 0 8 13% 77 0
644 Malatesta, Paul 1 0 8 13% 81 0
644 Krishnamurthy, Arvind 1 0 8 13% 104 0
644 Fisher, Adlai 1 0 8 13% 142 0
644 Bansal, Ravi 1 0 8 13% 147 0
686 Yonker, Scott E. 7 0 7 0% 16 0
686 Lyandres, Evgeny 7 0 7 0% 20 0
686 Gopalan, Radhakrishnan 7 0 7 0% 21 0
686 Darmouni, Olivier 2 0 7 29% 22 0
686 Borovicka, Jaroslav 7 0 7 0% 22 0
686 Bond, Philip 2 0 7 29% 23 0
686 Eric...See full post
570 531 525 Vorkink, Keith 10 0 10 0% 71 0
570 535 47 Asquith, Paul 2 0 10 20% 74 1
570 562 47 Hanson, Samuel G. 2 0 10 20% 88 0
570 565 311 Carr, Peter 1 0 10 10% 90 0
570 565 311 Myers, Stewart C. 1 0 10 10% 90 0
570 580 47 Blackwell, David 2 0 10 20% 98 0
606 Howell, Sabrina T. 9 0 9 0% 15 0
606 Sarno, Lucio 9 0 9 0% 19 0
606 Yang, Liyan 9 0 9 0% 20 0
606 Peyer, Urs C. 3 0 9 33% 21 0
606 Giroud, Xavier 1 0 9 11% 22 0
606 Cornell, Bradford 2 0 9 22% 23 0
606 Ai, Hengjie 9 0 9 0% 23 0
606 Gao, Janet 9 0 9 0% 23 0
606 Nyborg, Kjell 9 0 9 0% 23 0
606 Ewens, Michael 1 0 9 11% 25 0
606 Gerardi, Kristopher 1 0 9 11% 26 0
606 Kuehn, Lars-Alexander 1 0 9 11% 26 0
606 Bena, Jan 9 0 9 0% 26 0
606 Walden, Johan 2 0 9 22% 27 0
606 Kisgen, Darren James 9 0 9 0% 27 0
606 Kempf, Elisabeth 1 0 9 11% 28 0
606 Zwick, Eric 1 0 9 11% 28 0
606 Aggarwal, Rajesh K. 1 0 9 11% 29 0
606 Tian, Xuan 1 0 9 11% 31 0
606 Nanda, Ramana 1 0 9 11% 32 0
606 Schallheim, James S. 2 0 9 22% 33 0
606 Kim, Hyunseob 9 0 9 0% 33 0
606 Brennan, Michael J. 1 0 9 11% 36 1
606 Glover, Brent 1 0 9 11% 39 0
606 Milbradt, Konstantin 1 0 9 11% 42 0
606 Winton, Andrew 1 0 9 11% 43 0
606 Sheehan, Dennis 1 0 9 11% 45 0
606 Bharath, Sreedhar T. 9 0 9 0% 49 0
606 Hayes, Rachel 9 0 9 0% 51 0
606 Lusardi, Annamaria 2 0 9 22% 52 0
606 Wilhelm, William J. 1 0 9 11% 52 0
606 Mele, Antonio 2 0 9 22% 54 0
606 Jensen, Michael 3 0 9 33% 57 1
606 Gomes, Joao F. 1 0 9 11% 60 0
606 Vuolteenaho, Tuomo 1 0 9 11% 60 0
606 Nanda, Vikram K. 9 0 9 0% 73 0
606 Carlson, Murray 2 0 9 22% 113 0
606 Cohen, Randolph 1 0 9 11% 118 0
644 Vetsuypens, Michael 2 0 8 25% 16 0
644 Claessens, Stijin 1 0 8 13% 16 0
644 Zhong, Hongda 1 0 8 13% 18 0
644 Giannetti, Mariassunta 8 0 8 0% 18 0
644 Yan, Hongjun 1 0 8 13% 19 0
644 Manela, Asaf 8 0 8 0% 22 0
644 Hebert, Benjamin 2 0 8 25% 23 0
644 Derrien, Francois 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Gao, Pengjie (Paul) 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Maug, Ernst 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Sosyura, Denis 1 0 8 13% 24 0
644 Farre-Mensa, Joan 8 0 8 0% 24 0
644 Bigio, Saki 1 0 8 13% 25 0
644 Jacobs, Kris 1 0 8 13% 25 0
644 Beck, Thorsten 1 0 8 13% 26 0
644 Goldman, Eitan 8 0 8 0% 26 0
644 Boyer, Brian 1 0 8 13% 27 0
644 Pagel, Michaela 1 0 8 13% 27 0
644 Xiao, Kairong 1 0 8 13% 27 0
644 Haddad, Valentin 1 0 8 13% 28 0
644 Appel, Ian R. 8 0 8 0% 28 0
644 Benzoni, Luca 1 0 8 13% 30 0
644 George, Thomas J. 1 0 8 13% 31 0
644 Brown, Gregory W. 8 0 8 0% 32 0
644 Loutskina, Elena 8 0 8 0% 32 0
644 Simsek, Alp 2 0 8 25% 33 0
644 Schrand, Catherine 8 0 8 0% 34 0
644 Beshears, John 2 0 8 25% 41 0
644 Siriwardane, Emil N. 1 0 8 13% 43 0
644 McCormick, Robert 2 0 8 25% 45 0
644 Lewis, Craig M. 1 0 8 13% 45 0
644 Wedig, Gerard 8 0 8 0% 45 0
644 Bris, Arturo 8 0 8 0% 47 0
644 McNichols, Maureen 2 0 8 25% 53 0
644 Carey, Mark 1 0 8 13% 56 0
644 Lewellen, Katharina 8 0 8 0% 69 0
644 Smith, Abbie J. 2 0 8 25% 74 0
644 Bradshaw, Mark 1 0 8 13% 77 0
644 Malatesta, Paul 1 0 8 13% 81 0
644 Krishnamurthy, Arvind 1 0 8 13% 104 0
644 Fisher, Adlai 1 0 8 13% 142 0
644 Bansal, Ravi 1 0 8 13% 147 0
686 Yonker, Scott E. 7 0 7 0% 16 0
686 Lyandres, Evgeny 7 0 7 0% 20 0
686 Gopalan, Radhakrishnan 7 0 7 0% 21 0
686 Darmouni, Olivier 2 0 7 29% 22 0
686 Borovicka, Jaroslav 7 0 7 0% 22 0
686 Bond, Philip 2 0 7 29% 23 0
...See full post
I honestly don't know why the top 3 issued a statement that they disapproved of letting the profession know the rejection rates of referees. Is there no accountability? I thought finance academe believed in transparency. It is not like we know if any of these guys were our referees.