Finance folks, how do you rank these three and what is the rank of your department?
JFQA, Review of Finance, and Management Science
-
-
so many threads on this... but hey, let's do it again...
Now: JFQA~MS~>RF
In 3 years: RF~MS~>JFQA -
Each are better than the other. Or worse. Perhaps both
-
FTFY
so many threads on this... but hey, let's do it again...
Now: JFQA~MS~>RF
In 3 years: JFQA~MS~>RF -
MS>RoF~JFQA
-
What about the Journal of Empirical Finance?
-
It is meaningless to compare them. They are almost the same, i.e., JFQA = MS = ROF
-
JFQA>MS>>ROF
-
MS has by far the best set of finance editors of the three.
-
JF JFE RFS = Top5
RF MS JFQA = Top fields
Any bibliometrics say so. Recruiting and tenure committees behave consistently.
-
Not sure,
many still use expression Top 4 for finance journals and that top 4 is JFQA.JF JFE RFS = Top5
RF MS JFQA = Top fields
Any bibliometrics say so. Recruiting and tenure committees behave consistently. -
Not sure,
many still use expression Top 4 for finance journals and that top 4 is JFQA.No. It is not true.
-
MS is clearly the best
-
There is only a top three in finance. But it is fair to say JFQA gets special treatment in many tenure decisions outside the top schools. For example many tenure committees say you can substitute one of your A's with a JFQA, but only one.
-
The above is a bit ambiguous as to whether you can substitute one (and only one) of your A's with a MS?
Yes or no?
-
I've heard of substituting a JFQA. I've not heard anyone do it with MS. Though it is a positive signal.
Review of Finance doesn't even enter into the question.
The above is a bit ambiguous as to whether you can substitute one (and only one) of your A's with a MS?
Yes or no? -
What's the school ranking you are talking about?
I've heard of substituting a JFQA. I've not heard anyone do it with MS. Though it is a positive signal.
Review of Finance doesn't even enter into the question. -
^^ I've heard of the substitution at UNSW finance, but that's only because Masulis never published 1 paper at MS and has many pubs at JFQA... I suspect it's not a general case at all, but I could be wrong (?)
-
RoF > MS> JFQA
-
In my department RF~MS> Jfqa . Jfqa went down
RoF > MS> JFQA