OMG, again??
JFQA, Review of Finance, and Management Science
-
-
^^ could u please tell us if in your department 1 A pu can be substituted by 1 RF or 1 MS?
^ 0326, u should read better; the substitution thing hasn't been discussed before, no need to pollute this thread
-
Review of Finance and Management Science now publish better stuff than JFQA.
Between Review of Finance and Management Science? I don't know, I would be indifferent -
JFQA if you are up for tenure soon
MS if you are already tenure
RoF if you are in Europe.
End of story.
-
Review of Finance and Management Science now publish better stuff than JFQA.
Between Review of Finance and Management Science? I don't know, I would be indifferent
true
JF JFE RFS = Top 5
RF MS JFQA = Top fields -
Exactly
JFQA if you are up for tenure soon
MS if you are already tenure
RoF if you are in Europe.
End of story. -
MS probably helps a little more here, because it is viewed more favorably outside the finance department.
However, within the department, there is very little distinction between the three. RoF may have a slight discount at the moment because some old dogs are slow to update their views.
-
where do you send your papers first, JFQA or RoF?
MS probably helps a little more here, because it is viewed more favorably outside the finance department.
However, within the department, there is very little distinction between the three. RoF may have a slight discount at the moment because some old dogs are slow to update their views. -
I send to JFQA first. I don't think there is a significant difference in quality, but I still think more people in the US view JFQA more favorably.
-
It would be useful if people stated the rank of their school. My perception is that HRMs view MS as superior to JFQA and LRMs do the opposite.
-
I would tend to think the same. Thanks
I send to JFQA first. I don't think there is a significant difference in quality, but I still think more people in the US view JFQA more favorably.
-
What's the school ranking you are talking about?
I've heard of substituting a JFQA. I've not heard anyone do it with MS. Though it is a positive signal.
Review of Finance doesn't even enter into the question.
Top 50-100?
-
Do you thinkthe three journals have different taste?
-
RoF=JFQA=MS
I send to RoF first, I heard some now consider it strictly above the other two
where do you send your papers first, JFQA or RoF?
MS probably helps a little more here, because it is viewed more favorably outside the finance department.
However, within the department, there is very little distinction between the three. RoF may have a slight discount at the moment because some old dogs are slow to update their views.
-
JF JFE RFS = Top 5
RF MS JFQA = Top fields -
In our school (LRM),
JFQA=MS.
ROF is not counted.
-
JF JFE RFS = Top 5
RF MS JFQA = Top fields
-
All are in toilet. Top 5 econ. that's the only thing that really sets you apart from the rest of the animals in a zoo.
-
In our school RoF and MS count more than JFQA (marginally)
-
In our school, US top 100, MS = JFQA. MS is slightly better than JFQA since the dean likes MS. We don't count RoF.