OP had around 30 good and 2 nogood, and people were expressing concerns about her paper, not much more.
Sounds like a free referee service. How about posting a link to your paper, and we can do the same? ;)
I started this thread, I did not start the previous one that was deleted. Some people here get pretty nervous when this paper is discussed, much less when trolls trash other papers such as Dust Bowl or Barbed Wire. I wonder why this paper is sacred and people reply with personal attacks. If you have seen some other papers that placed in top schools that had mistakes, you are welcome to post them here. The quality of the discussion will increase, and probably also the use of your time. Why is it ok to trash Bruno Frey and self plagiarism and not papers with mistakes? If you think this thread has no reason to exist and the paper is amazing, just prove it. Otherwise, GTFO!