Close

Complete Captcha

• 1 week - 25 posts - Latest - RSS
• Thread: 12 Goods vs 12 No Goods

1. Economist
   03ee
   

   how many are usually requested nowadays? Is the number hugely different for well known people at top institutions and the unknowns

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

2. Economist
   4335
   

   3

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

3. Economist
   497b
   

   usually club members and their phd students (i.e., future club members),b ut they sometimes reach out to loosers like me on specific topics

   1 week ago # QUOTE 1 Good 0 No Good !

4. Economist
   4aa2
   

   i, obviously unknown, got 2 from AER

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

5. Economist
   03ee
   

   much fewer than i expected!

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

6. Economist
   62f1
   

   Four is reasonably common now, with one extra if it's a close call. Editors are too busy to read the papers themselves. It all seems rather inefficient.

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

7. Economist
   3b9a
   

   I had 4.

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

8. Economist
   40b9
   

   The reports could be fairly long. So is it really more efficient for the editor to read multiple reports than the paper itself?

   1 week ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

9. Economist
   44c2
   

   Promising papers get more.

   6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

10. Economist
    eb8b
    

    Got 4 from AER, rejection.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

11. Economist
    50be
    

    What is this top 5 you speak of?
    There are 4 top journals; AER, QJE, ECMA, JPE.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 2 Good 6 No Good !

12. Economist
    a5a1
    

    Once I have seen six referees.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

13. Economist
    20af
    

    I'd say 3 is modal and 4 is more common than 2. 5 is absurd but does happen occasionally.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

14. Economist
    8984
    

    Alright, something like 100 comments then for the person to address.

    Once I have seen six referees.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

15. Economist
    0bab
    

    Go read the journal wiki.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

16. Economist
    e718
    

    Had 5 at ECMA.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Good !

17. Economist
    d097
    

    What is this top 5 you speak of?
    There are 4 top journals; AER, QJE, ECMA, JPE.

    Obviously, ReStud.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 0 Good 2 No Good !

18. Economist
    ad52
    

    What is this top 5 you speak of?
    There are 4 top journals; AER, QJE, ECMA, JPE.

    Obviously, ReStud.

    ReStud is a 2nd tier general interest, albeit the best of them, but it’s not a top journal

    6 days ago # QUOTE 1 Good 2 No Good !

19. Economist
    fe4f
    

    If you're LRM, the editor will pick more referees until a referee recommends reject.

    If you're HRM, the editor will pick more referees until a referee recommends r&r.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 2 Good 0 No Good !

20. Economist
    fe4f
    

    What is this top 5 you speak of?
    There are 4 top journals; AER, QJE, ECMA, JPE.

    Obviously, ReStud.

    ReStud is a 2nd tier general interest, albeit the best of them, but it’s not a top journal

    I'd argue that the median ReStud paper is better than the median QJE or AER paper.

    6 days ago # QUOTE 3 Good 2 No Good !

Reply »