What is the average assistant professor's salary in tier 1 schools?
Official Accounting JM Thread 2022
-
If you’ve been a faculty member for a few years, you should know whose letter mean something and whose don’t. Saying every PhD student is an RA when working with faculty is silly, you need to know what people you can trust to tell the truth and who will get people involved in real work.
It’s called your job.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them. -
Pretty much. For (1), you can also add: are they from MIT or Wharton? If yes, then they will get on average 3 low-cited JAE pubs coauthored with JAE editors in the next three years.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them. -
I just said not to trust the letters. Some mean something, some don’t. You have to screen somehow, you can’t talk to every candidate.
^ Go ahead trust the letters. I’d rather do my own due diligence based on conversations with the candidate. I dont care how good the letters are, if the person cant manage an intellectual conversation about something other than job market paper … TOAST
-
^ Go ahead trust the letters. I’d rather do my own due diligence based on conversations with the candidate. I dont care how good the letters are, if the person cant manage an intellectual conversation about something other than job market paper … TOAST
Someone tried talking to me (candidate) about their own work. FAIL.
-
JAR conference seems to be out! That's a LOT of proposals...there's no way they take all of them, right?
https://research.chicagobooth.edu/arc/journal-of-accounting-research/2021-registered-reports/registered-reportsis there any research at booth? Lololol
At bare minimum, judging by the number of proposals coming from Booth alumni, Booth seems to think highly of the research done there and coming out of there?
-
JAR conference seems to be out! That's a LOT of proposals...there's no way they take all of them, right?
https://research.chicagobooth.edu/arc/journal-of-accounting-research/2021-registered-reports/registered-reportsis there any research at booth? Lololol
At bare minimum, judging by the number of proposals coming from Booth alumni, Booth seems to think highly of the research done there and coming out of there?
Looks like 2 of 14 proposals and 3 of 43 proposal authors are Booth alumni. Those are high numbers?
-
Please name at least one JAR pub from the most recent 5 years edited by a Booth grad's advisor. I can tell that math is hard for you, so to assist you please note that the most recent 5 years are 2017 - 2021 inclusive. Thanks.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them. -
What’s the difference between being edited by an advisor and being edited by a committee member? Even JAR’s outside editors are like a friends and family special event.
Please name at least one JAR pub from the most recent 5 years edited by a Booth grad's advisor. I can tell that math is hard for you, so to assist you please note that the most recent 5 years are 2017 - 2021 inclusive. Thanks.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them. -
When confronted about blatant lies, the ones telling the blatant lies aim to shift the story a bit. Trump would be proud of you.
What’s the difference between being edited by an advisor and being edited by a committee member? Even JAR’s outside editors are like a friends and family special event.
Please name at least one JAR pub from the most recent 5 years edited by a Booth grad's advisor. I can tell that math is hard for you, so to assist you please note that the most recent 5 years are 2017 - 2021 inclusive. Thanks.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them. -
Or are you just "friends and family" of the blatant liar, which according to your own "logic" makes you a blatant liar yourself?
When confronted about blatant lies, the ones telling the blatant lies aim to shift the story a bit. Trump would be proud of you.
What’s the difference between being edited by an advisor and being edited by a committee member? Even JAR’s outside editors are like a friends and family special event.
Please name at least one JAR pub from the most recent 5 years edited by a Booth grad's advisor. I can tell that math is hard for you, so to assist you please note that the most recent 5 years are 2017 - 2021 inclusive. Thanks.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them. -
Please name at least one JAR pub from the most recent 5 years edited by a Booth grad's advisor. I can tell that math is hard for you, so to assist you please note that the most recent 5 years are 2017 - 2021 inclusive. Thanks.
Hiring Decision:
1- Are they from Chicago? If yes, they will get on average 3 low-cited JAR pubs in the next three years, most of which will be edited by their advisors. JOB.
2- For all others… does the JMP seem plausible and can they have an intellectual and insightful conversation about something other than their JMP? If yes, JOB.
Counting faculty/student coauthored pubs leads to selection on RAs. Reading letters is introducing noise. Some advisors always have their best student on the market. Some advisors are just incapable of being kind and writing letters. Some advisors are delusional and think the world of the student only because the student worships them.challenge accepted
https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-679X.12255NEXT !