I doubt you even have 1 publication
Official Marketing JM 2020 Thread
-
Have a Marketing Science, two Journal of Marketing and in addition an R&R at Maketing Science....everybody told me how great this is but I was not even invited at my preferred place. Instead a guy received an offer with a Management Science and a QME. Why????
Places that value QME do not value Journal of Marketing.
-
Have a Marketing Science, two Journal of Marketing and in addition an R&R at Maketing Science....everybody told me how great this is but I was not even invited at my preferred place. Instead a guy received an offer with a Management Science and a QME. Why????
As a rookie or AP? I think this record is great, isn't it?
-
Have a Marketing Science, two Journal of Marketing and in addition an R&R at Maketing Science....everybody told me how great this is but I was not even invited at my preferred place. Instead a guy received an offer with a Management Science and a QME. Why????
As a rookie or AP? I think this record is great, isn't it?
It's tricky. At most top schools schools like Stanford, Chicago, MIT, Yale etc. JM and JM style papers just don't fly. At others schools the record might be considered great. It's a matter of taste and fit I guess.
-
Have a Marketing Science, two Journal of Marketing and in addition an R&R at Maketing Science....everybody told me how great this is but I was not even invited at my preferred place. Instead a guy received an offer with a Management Science and a QME. Why????
Welcome to the real world. You now know that academia doesn't work based on meritocracy. More important are 1) whether you are a diversity candidate, 2) your chair's network and willingness to help you, 3) all other cr@p.
-
Marketing has it's problems, but you know what?, this are coming out because people are fed up. CT has, let's just put it that way, non-transparent data policy. In one journal the treatment is randomized, in another, maybe it's just a "natural experiment." Good joke! After I have seen first hand, I cannot treat any papers by CT seriously.
EIC of MS is a serous guy, he has an engineering spin, and does not tolerate BS. I hope that JG would be removed by EIC of MS once he learns about it. This is abnormal treatment and very unethical.Does this happen in Marketing Departments frequently? Friends accept and publish Management Sciences in three months!
Marketing teacher in question: CT
Used her friend JG as Senior Editor to gets two Management Science Publications: Look at the turnaround time of these papers and match them with the low quality. JG and CT wrote grants together (Sloan Foundation) and organize conference together (https://www.economicsofai.com/nber-conference-2018)
Paper-1: Algorithmic Bias? An Empirical Study into Apparent Gender-Based Discrimination in
the Display of STEM Career Ads
Editor: JG (Received:November 28, 2017 / Accepted:March 13, 2018)
Paper-2: Collusion by Algorithm: Does Better Demand Prediction Facilitate Coordination
Between Sellers?
Editor: JG (Received:October 05, 2018 / Accepted:December 28, 2018) -
Before CT is gone, you are gone.
Hah, CT strong! SS is gone from the field, CT is next.
They are not fast track, regular submissions, taking to the VERY pissed insider here. MS has scaled down behavioral quite a bit, not enough apparently.
Does this happen in Marketing Departments frequently? Friends accept and publish Management Sciences in three months!
Marketing teacher in question: CT
Used her friend JG as Senior Editor to gets two Management Science Publications: Look at the turnaround time of these papers and match them with the low quality. JG and CT wrote grants together (Sloan Foundation) and organize conference together (https://www.economicsofai.com/nber-conference-2018)
Paper-1: Algorithmic Bias? An Empirical Study into Apparent Gender-Based Discrimination in
the Display of STEM Career Ads
Editor: JG (Received:November 28, 2017 / Accepted:March 13, 2018)
Paper-2: Collusion by Algorithm: Does Better Demand Prediction Facilitate Coordination
Between Sellers?
Editor: JG (Received:October 05, 2018 / Accepted:December 28, 2018)Both of those papers are fast track (look at their length, they are under 5000 words). Fast track publications take under 3 months.
and they are clearly not "low quality"! Especially the STEM paper. Did you even read them?