Tenure is not easy, folks.
Official Marketing JM 2023 Thread
-
^ Most of his papers are on the topic of social class and published in psychology journals. Maybe there was a question about his fit with a business school.
That seems to be the case. Most of his pubs are in psychology outlets. Not a great cv for a business school.
Based on his tweets, he seems to be a major doo-sh-bag.
I propose a new metric for evaluating tenure cases:
Total number of A publications minus average Tweets per day
By that measure he seems to be net negative.
-
I try not to Twitter but it’s a thing our comms folks want us to do. I don’t get it. It’s only downside risk. I mean, if I were tenured, maybe I’d pull a dril
^ Most of his papers are on the topic of social class and published in psychology journals. Maybe there was a question about his fit with a business school.
That seems to be the case. Most of his pubs are in psychology outlets. Not a great cv for a business school.
Based on his tweets, he seems to be a major doo-sh-bag.
I propose a new metric for evaluating tenure cases:
Total number of A publications minus average Tweets per day
By that measure he seems to be net negative. -
Doesn’t he have like 55 or so psych A’s? He has 33 in 4 years at Yale
^ Most of his papers are on the topic of social class and published in psychology journals. Maybe there was a question about his fit with a business school.
That seems to be the case. Most of his pubs are in psychology outlets. Not a great cv for a business school.
Based on his tweets, he seems to be a major doo-sh-bag.
I propose a new metric for evaluating tenure cases:
Total number of A publications minus average Tweets per day
By that measure he seems to be net negative. -
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.
-
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.How is “poor people are nicer and more generous than rich people” relevant to business? Honest question.
-
Brian Nosek said he was top 3 in the subfield. My read on his recent work is it’s quite well done (pre registered, good designs, appropriate) and interesting.
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business. -
If you can’t intuit why the social psychology of class is important generally and more specifically to managers, I don’t think anyone can convince you.
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.How is “poor people are nicer and more generous than rich people” relevant to business? Honest question.
-
If you can’t intuit why the social psychology of class is important generally and more specifically to managers, I don’t think anyone can convince you.
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.How is “poor people are nicer and more generous than rich people” relevant to business? Honest question.
I can intuit some implications. The result implies if you open a business in a poor neighborhood you do not need to put bars on the windows or hire security. Unfortunately this result is not true.
-
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.Then, he should move to a top psych program. Let's see if a top psych department makes him an offer.
-
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.Then, he should move to a top psych program. Let's see if a top psych department makes him an offer.
Agreed. Business schools are for those who do business.
-
If you can’t intuit why the social psychology of class is important generally and more specifically to managers, I don’t think anyone can convince you.
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.How is “poor people are nicer and more generous than rich people” relevant to business? Honest question.
The truth is that academic research done in business schools has little importance to businesses. Name one scholar whose contributions have significantly changed business practice? Hard to think of one, at least in marketing and management. Perhaps the field of research that ha had the most influence in marketing is research in priming, but now we know that this whole area doesn't replicate and is probably just noise.
-
Keller at Dartmouth (brand equity model).
If you can’t intuit why the social psychology of class is important generally and more specifically to managers, I don’t think anyone can convince you.
As a CBer, MK at Yale had certainly earned tenure. His papers might be published in good psych journals, but the topics are clearly relevant to business and OB. Please look at the work, not only at whether it is published in 'the' journals.
Any top psych program would have tenured him, and their demands do not differ much from business.How is “poor people are nicer and more generous than rich people” relevant to business? Honest question.
The truth is that academic research done in business schools has little importance to businesses. Name one scholar whose contributions have significantly changed business practice? Hard to think of one, at least in marketing and management. Perhaps the field of research that ha had the most influence in marketing is research in priming, but now we know that this whole area doesn't replicate and is probably just noise.