^Maybe not at your ULR university
PNAS submission
-
Should one follow the style requirements on the first submission? they are too boring! it would take so much time to go through them...
Yeah, the editorial assistants will bounce any paper beyond the specified page limits.
just that, or all other requirements??
-
Should one follow the style requirements on the first submission? they are too boring! it would take so much time to go through them...
so i got "pending final recommendations" update following "under editorial board review". does that mean it passed the editorial board and i will get the style requirements email from assistants and then it will go to peer review.. i though i would get rejection letter soon! :)
-
I mean how does it compare to a top-5 econ?
I would say roughly equivalent, but there is a very high variance in the quality of social science papers in PNAS, Science, and Nature (they like the sexy, surprising stuff, which is often wrong).
Top 5 dominate it for economists, but no other journals do.
-
this has happened to me too ("under editorial board review" -> "pending final recommendation"), but its been like that for a few days. Can someone confirm this is a rejection?
Sorry, desk reject.
If you'd made it past the board, it would've changed to editor assigned (I forget the exact wording).