^Maybe not at your ULR university
PNAS submission
-
Should one follow the style requirements on the first submission? they are too boring! it would take so much time to go through them...
so i got "pending final recommendations" update following "under editorial board review". does that mean it passed the editorial board and i will get the style requirements email from assistants and then it will go to peer review.. i though i would get rejection letter soon! :)
-
I mean how does it compare to a top-5 econ?
I would say roughly equivalent, but there is a very high variance in the quality of social science papers in PNAS, Science, and Nature (they like the sexy, surprising stuff, which is often wrong).
Top 5 dominate it for economists, but no other journals do.
-
this has happened to me too ("under editorial board review" -> "pending final recommendation"), but its been like that for a few days. Can someone confirm this is a rejection?
Sorry, desk reject.
If you'd made it past the board, it would've changed to editor assigned (I forget the exact wording).