mine is Under editorial board review, then Editor assigned and then pending final recommendation. possibly rejected.
All, here is my PNAS current status...what does this mean? Has it been rejected by the Ed Board?
Pending Final Recommendation
Under Editorial Board Review
Quality Control Review Completed
Quality Control Review Started
Author Approved Submission
Waiting for Author Approval of Converted Files
Waiting for File Conversion
I have a paper that made it to review. Here is the status.
Stage Start Date
Under Review 2015-01-22
Under Editor Review 2015-01-21
Under Editorial Board Review 2015-01-12
Quality Control Review Completed 2015-01-12
Quality Control Review Started 2015-01-09
Author Approved Submission 2015-01-09
Waiting for Author Approval of Converted Files 2015-01-09
Waiting for File Conversion 2015-01-09
mine is Under editorial board review, then Editor assigned and then pending final recommendation. possibly rejected.
All, here is my PNAS current status...what does this mean? Has it been rejected by the Ed Board?
Pending Final Recommendation
Under Editorial Board Revi
Pending Final Recommendation 2016-07-12
Under Review 2016-07-12
Under Editor Review 2016-07-12
Under Editorial Board Review 2016-06-27
Quality Control Review Completed 2016-06-27
Quality Control Review Started 2016-06-24
Author Approved Submission 2016-06-24
Preliminary Manuscript Information Submitted
Could somebody tell me what "pending for final recommendation" after "under review" on same day?
Thanks
Pending Final Recommendation 2016-07-12
Under Review 2016-07-12
Under Editor Review 2016-07-12
Under Editorial Board Review 2016-06-27
Quality Control Review Completed 2016-06-27
Quality Control Review Started 2016-06-24
Author Approved Submission 2016-06-24
Preliminary Manuscript Information Submitted
Could somebody tell me what "pending for final recommendation" after "under review" on same day?
Thanks
You're getting rejected. The editor didn't send it out for review. Sorry.
Hi guys,
Mine is sitting on EB review for more than 3 wks now, is there any chance that the system does not say even though it went to further steps, or should I think it is literally sitting on EB's desk?
Thanks.
Never mind, just changed into under editor review. Thanks.
What about this scenario:
Pending Recommendation
Under Editorial Board Review
Quality Control Review Completed
Quality Control Issue Identified
Quality Control Review Started
Author Approved Submission
The key difference from the others mention on this page is the word "final". Supposedly, "Pending Recommendation" should only happen after Under Review. If it was a desk rejection then it should say "pending final recommendation".......That being said, I am pretty sure it is a rejection.
Any idea what this means?
Pending Recommendation 2017-11-09
Under Review 2017-11-08
Under Editor Review 2017-11-08
Under Editorial Board Review 2017-10-26
Quality Control Review Completed 2017-10-26
Quality Control Review Started 2017-10-26
Author Approved Submission 2017-10-26
Waiting for Author Approval of Converted Files 2017-10-26
Waiting for File Conversion 2017-10-26
Any idea what this means?
Pending Recommendation 2017-11-09
Under Review 2017-11-08
Under Editor Review 2017-11-08
Under Editorial Board Review 2017-10-26
Quality Control Review Completed 2017-10-26
Quality Control Review Started 2017-10-26
Author Approved Submission 2017-10-26
Waiting for Author Approval of Converted Files 2017-10-26
Waiting for File Conversion 2017-10-26
Did you get a decision?
What about this scenario:
Pending Recommendation
Under Editorial Board Review
Quality Control Review Completed
Quality Control Issue Identified
Quality Control Review Started
Author Approved Submission
The key difference from the others mention on this page is the word "final". Supposedly, "Pending Recommendation" should only happen after Under Review. If it was a desk rejection then it should say "pending final recommendation".......That being said, I am pretty sure it is a rejection.
Was the "pending recommendation" followed by a rejection?
Any idea what this means?
Pending Recommendation 2017-11-09
Under Review 2017-11-08
Under Editor Review 2017-11-08
Under Editorial Board Review 2017-10-26
Quality Control Review Completed 2017-10-26
Quality Control Review Started 2017-10-26
Author Approved Submission 2017-10-26
Waiting for Author Approval of Converted Files 2017-10-26
Waiting for File Conversion 2017-10-26
did you get a decision? And what is it?