My paper is now under review for 9 days at QJE(including a weekend). Does it mean that my paper has survived the desk rejection? And conditional on surviving, what is the probability of getting a Rejection, an RR, a conditional acceptance and etc.
QJE desk rejection time and R&R probability
-
My paper is now under review for 9 days at QJE(including a weekend). Does it mean that my paper has survived the desk rejection? And conditional on surviving, what is the probability of getting a Rejection, an RR, a conditional acceptance and etc.
Mine was desk rejected 3 hours after submission. It was this year.
-
Katz is mythe cordiforme for my paper, Nathan Nunn is the editor for my paper. I know the probability of getting an RR is really low, especially for someone like me who hasn’t established a reputation in the academia
qje is fast on desk rejection (especially katz). 9 days almost certainly means you'll get reports. they desk reject over half, but r&r only about 3% i think. so surviving desk rejection raises the unconditional r&r probability to 6%.
-
Who was your paper’s editor?
My paper is now under review for 9 days at QJE(including a weekend). Does it mean that my paper has survived the desk rejection? And conditional on surviving, what is the probability of getting a Rejection, an RR, a conditional acceptance and etc.
Mine was desk rejected 3 hours after submission. It was this year.